Jerome Spillman (1857-1858)
Jacob Adriance (1858-1859)
L. W. Smith (1859-1860)
David Hart (1860-1861)
Theodore Hoagland (1861-1862)
J. H. Alling (1862-1863)
Martin Pritchard (1863-1865)
Jacob Adriance (1865-1867)
Joel A. VanAnda(1867-1870)
E. J. Mechesney (1870)
Geo. W. DeLaMatyr (1872-1873)
J. M. Richards (1873-1875)
C. G. Lathrop (1875-1876)
Geo. W. DeLaMatyr (1876-1878)
L. B. Long (1878-1879)
J. W. Shank (1879-1881)
W. F. Warren (1881-1883)
J. Fowler (1883-1884)
G. M. Brown (1884-1887)
T. B. Hilton (1887-1889)
J. W. Robinson (1889-1892)
G. M. Brown (1892-1894)
F. M. Sisson (1894-1897)
W. P. Murray (1897-1899)
F. H. Sanderson (1899-1905)
J. A. Spyker (1905-1908)
Thos. Bithell (1908-1911)
F. M. Sisson (1911-1917)
Emory Hull (1917-1922)
L. E. Baker (1922-1925)
E. T. Connely (1925-1926)
F. E. Pfoutz (1926-1930)
Hal Schenck (1930-1935)
E. H. Maynard (1935-38)
Paul Philipp (1938-41)
Paul Hillman (1941-1947)
A. V. Hunter (1947-1953)
Max O. McCamley (1953-1958)
Ella A. Powell (Associate Pastor 1958-1963)
J. Graydon Wilson (1958-1968)
Robert Peterson (Associate Pastor 1964-1965)
Truman Bachenberg (Associate Pastor 1966-1968)
William C. Simmer (1968-1973)
Laurence R. Davis (1973-1978)
Eugene E. Watson (1973-1978)
Merle A. Zook (1978-1984)
Harold Backus (Associate Pastor 1978-1981)
Harold N. Smith (Associate Pastor 1981-1984)
Joseph A. Scahill (1984-1991)
Kelly Karges (Associate Pastor 1984-1988)
Carol Roettmer Brewer (1991-1994)
Thomas Martin (Associate Pastor 1989-1994)
Ron Croom (1994-1998)
Brian Kottas (Associate Pastor 1994-1999)
Eugene E. Watson (1998-2001)
J. Green (Associate Pastor 1999-2001)
Jocelyn Tupper (2001-2005)
Laurie Morrison (Associate Pastor 2001-2002)
Melanie Adams (Associate Pastor 2002-2005)
Ron Croom (2005-2009)
Greg Hall (Associate Pastor 2002-present)
Michael McGregor (2009-present)
